A Change Of Course

Boot Camp is very good, but I felt a need to see more positions to illustrate some of what I was learning and was having trouble creating my own positions. This lead to Robertie’s 501 Essential Backgammon Problems, which I found myself reading more than Boot Camp recently. Maybe it is my learning style, or where I am at in my backgammon education, but I feel like I am getting more out of 501 than Boot Camp at the moment. I am not abandoning Boot Camp but I am going to add some things from 501 as I go along here, because the real purpose of this blog is to learn backgammon.

501 was written in the early days of bots, and whether it was the rollout setting or the power of the bot at the time or just Robertie not believing the bot there are some problems in 501 where the solutions are incorrect. But, most of these are going to be small errors for someone playing at the level of those of us interested in this blog, and there is always the bot double check.

From some of the discussion on the bgonline.org forum there has evidently been a project to roll out all of the positions in 501, but it is – as far as I can tell—not published. I would guess this is because publishing all of the positions in the book would likely be considered a copyright infringement as this is the majority of the content.

Another criticism I have seen of 501 is that not all candidate rolls are discussed and that sometimes the alternative candidates that are discussed are not the second best alternative. I am guessing that part of the reason for limiting the discussion is to keep the book relatively brief. I also think that often the alternatives that are discussed are those that a lower level player might jump to, so for the level of audience the book is intended it makes sense to discuss them.

I am skipping the chapter on the opening rolls for now, as I am going to be studying several other sources regarding the opening. Perhaps a more systematic approach where I study each aspect of the game in turn would be a better approach, but I am finding that may play is improving considerably by picking up more knowledge about aspect of the game as I can.


2 thoughts on “A Change Of Course

  1. Various people have rolled out all the positions in 501, including Michael Depreli and Stick Rice. I agree that publishing all the rollouts including the positions would be a copyright violation and that this is probably one reason the rollouts have not been published.

    However, I believe that publishing the rollouts only, numbering them but not giving any indication of what the position is, would not be a copyright violation. I am hoping to do this at some point, at least for the positions where there is a discrepancy between what Robertie says and what the bot says. However, at the moment I’m not promising when exactly I will complete this project.

  2. I think you are correct, the rollouts alone without showing the positions would not be of any value without possession of the copyrighted material. I had not thought of publishing them that way, but it would be a great help to those of us studying the material. I will be publishing rollouts of some positions here, especially those I find of particular interest or where Robertie’s answer is not in agreement with gnubg. Feel free to grab any of them to include in your rollout project if you wish.

    Given the price of the book a cannot see a reason to do it, but I am curious how many of the positions could be collected from blogs, forums, etc. if one wanted to try to reproduce all of them.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s